Every Penn Stater knows the Berkey Creamery boasts incredible ice cream, but nearly every townie would suggest Meyer Dairy serves up the superior scoops.

This week, our staff set out to settle the debate…objectively. Blindfolded, we taste-tested five staple flavors from the Creamery and Meyer Dairy to determine whose ice cream ranks supreme.

So, are Creamery lines really worth the wait? Does Meyer Dairy deserve more clout than it gets? See what our staff thought below.